Travis Smith: my resume, bio and photos back to the main blog page

David Byrne talking about the relationship between music and the medium it’s stored on

http://journal.davidbyrne.com/2007/01/1207_crappy_sou.html

I personally wish MP3s were higher fidelity. But I think I'm mostly alone in that.

posted at 11:40 am
on Mar. 7, 2007

Permalink

Overheard

“Complaining is silly. Either act or forget.”

...who said it?

“To love is to stop comparing.”

...who said it?

“Let us face a pluralistic world in which there are no universal churches, no single remedy for all diseases, no one way to teach or write or sing, no magic diet, no world poets, and no chosen races, but only the wretched and wonderfully diversified human race.”

...who said it?

“Music is all about timing”

...who said it?

“I do something wrong: accident. You do something wrong: character flaw.”

...who said it?

Comments

 

 

You’re not alone, but it’s not so much a limitation of MP3s (you can always throw bitrate at them; somewhere around 200 kbps they become acoustically equivalent to CDs; somewhere around 350 kbps they become nearly equivalent to master tapes) as of either storage space or expectations.

Also, the codec is the least notable part of the medium, and easily swapped. Apple seamlessly juggles AIFF, Apple Lossless, MP3, AAC and more within iTunes; other programs do even more.

Byrne’s entry is a little odd in that it understands the problem (typical MP3 encoding rates make for noticeable sound deterioration) without understanding the fundamental problem (bitrates rather than the nature of the format, or even the medium).

Also, Tim Bray mentioned this very post with some cogent critiques.

 

Posted by Ryan Cousineau  at  11:03 pm on Mar. 10, 2007

 

 

 

Excellent points, and very true all.

 

Posted by Travis Smith  at  10:11 am on Mar. 15, 2007

Add a Comment

 

 

Name:


Email:


Location:


URL:


Submit the word you see below:


 

 

 

Your comment:


Remember my personal info


Email me about follow-ups


 

Syndication Links


Click here for the main
XML feed for this blog.



Column only



Side links only



Quotes only

 

I'm Listening To

2007/07/29 11:50

Zero 7
Garden State

MetaBlogs

AboutBlogs

Clients

Humor

Journalism

Los Angeles

Mac

News

Personal 1

Personal 2

Photos

Politics

Other A-F

Other G-Q

Other R-Z

SocialNetworking

Tech 1

Tech 2

Travel

Vancouver 1

Vancouver 2

Vancouver 3

Vancouver 4

BizBlogs

Back to Main

 

Powered by
Expression Engine

 

Copyright 1995 - 2005

 

 

Want Column?

Enter your email address:


It will NEVER be shared.
Unsubscribe

You can scroll right easily by holding down the SHIFT key and using your scroll wheel. (Firefox users trying this will end up jumping to old Web pages until a) Firefox releases a fix, b) they change their settings like so.)