My friend Darren’s considering not getting a TiVo. As Jon Stewart would say…. whaaaaaaa?
I have always been surprised by the gap between people who have used TiVo and love it, and those who haven’t and don’t. I had TiVo in the U.S. and it was a serious factor when we moved to Canada—that we’d have to give up TiVo.
I don’t watch much TV—went without cable for the first six months I was up here, and haven’t turned my TV on in the past three weeks. But that’s exactly the thing that TiVo is so good for—it enhances the little TV watching I do, making it a pleasure instead of a flirtation with irritation.
I understand that for some reason, those who haven’t had TiVo can’t imagine the benefits properly. I also remember thinking, why would a computer need a color screen, I can read text in monochrome green just fine. And what’s the big deal about FM radio, AM does the job perfectly.
I can also say that I have never, ever met someone who used TiVo who would willingly go without it.
The PVR options in Canada other than TiVo would have cost $700 for the unit PLUS a monthly fee, and that was over my pain threshold. But the cheapest 40-hour TiVo costs only $50 US after rebate, plus a $300 lifetime activation, and that’s well affordable.
Darren, buying a DVD recorder is like buying a CD Walkman—nothing wrong with it, but you’re missing out on a far superior, equally priced alternative.
(I will add one postscript—TiVo has recently implemented a flag that lets content owners BLOCK TiVo owners from keeping copies of certain shows around for more than 7 days. This is deplorable, and I hope TiVo reverses this as soon as possible.)
“Do stuff. Be clenched, curious. Not waiting for inspiration’s shove or society’s kiss on your forehead. Pay attention. It’s all about paying attention. Attention is vitality. It connects you with others. It makes you eager. Stay eager.”
“When, after a few years or a few months of a relationship, we find that we’re still unfulfilled, we blame our partners and take up with somebody more promising. This can go on and on—series polygamy—until we admit that while a partner can add sweet dimensions to our lives, we, each of us, are responsible for our own fulfillment. Nobody else can provide it for us, and to believe otherwise is to delude ourselves dangerously and to program for eventual failure every relationship we enter.”
I have used a Tivo-like feature before... and do not currently have Tivo. Affordable is, in fact, a relative term. I won't say I'll never get it. Of course, I probably won't, since most satellites and cable companies have a DVR option if I do in fact decide to reinstate what I agree to be a very neat feature of the TV viewing experience. (And trust me, I'm experienced!) Of course, this is just my opinion. Ask Travis what my opinion about email was.
See, I appreciate that a TiVo PVR is incrementally better than a DVD recorder, but not profoundly so.
Why, if we watch little television (and specific programs, as opposed to a little random surfing), does the TiVo make a huge difference?
More practically and personally, the current TiVo offering presents me with a couple problems:
1. I need to import it from the US, either by going down there and buying one, or presumably ordering one and having it shipped up.
2. I don't have Internet access in my livingroom, so I need to enable that. That costs money, but more importantly is a pain in the ass.
Add those potential costs to the US $350, and you get at least to US $450, which must be at least CAN $550. That, compared with CAN $300, is a significant difference.
I think it's worth noting that the rebate is only valid in the United States. I'm lucky enough to have some friends South of the border who can submit the rebate for me, and either mail the cheque or paypal the cash. But for those without American friends/family or a US PO Box, that $150 is a hefty punch in the wallet. Not only that, but acquiring the rebate enters you into a contract with TiVo that requires you sign onto their services for a full year (whether you pay monthly, or get the product lifetime subscription), and the early cancellation fee is, you guessed it, $150.
Of course, those things won't stop me from getting the unit and hoping for the best, but for others who aren't shameless TV Junkies like myself, it might not be worth it...
Debbie, you didn't use TiVo, and you didn't willingly give up your TiVo-like device, either.
Darren, your objections are one-time problems that, once solved, will fade in comparison to your TiVoJoy(tm). I agree that importation problem is a big one, but you surely know someone who's coming this way soon? You can use a phone line for partial functionality; that's what I used and it was enough.
Jen, the rebate issue is a valid one -- and again, I think that the fact you can't buy TiVo boxes in Canada is a one-time hurdle that shouldn't stop you from years of TiVo enjoyment.
Posted by Travis Smith at 4:19 pm on Sep. 27, 2005
I love TiVo, and anxiously waiting for the Canadian equivalent (is there ever going to be one?) As a fellow hardcore TV junkie, I too want to experience this TiVo Joy!
You can scroll right easily by holding down the SHIFT key and using your scroll wheel. (Firefox users trying this will end up jumping to old Web pages until a) Firefox releases a fix, b) they change their settings like so.)