Travis Smith: my resume, bio and photos back to the main blog page

Sustainable Pricing

posted at 4:14 pm
on Nov. 18, 2006

Comments: 6 so far

Permalink

 

Previous entry:
Needed: Americans Who Moved to Canada?

Next entry:
AJAX Programmer Needed

Have you ever had this happen to you: You have a thought in your head, a sort of big thought, like a new way to think about art, or a great invention, or a politic consequence that no one seems to be saying, and then you suddenly trip over that idea at a mall or in a newspaper?

It just happened to me.  I was wondering what life would be like if every item sold had to have its sustainable price put on it.

In other words, if you buy a cordless phone, if there was something on the package that said how much that company would have to charge if it was also responsible for making sure that phoen could be completely recycled to an earth-neutral substence.

Or how much they’d have to charge to ensure that they could go on making that phone model forever.

I mean, a phone is made out of plastic from fossil fuels, and rare earth metals, and maybe a bit of rubber.  Part of why you can buy it for $26.99, is that it’s produced using materials from the planet that the company will never replace.  It’s the same reason little kids can sell lemonade for $0.25 per cup—they’re taking sugar and ice from the house, and they don’t have to replace them.

How much would that phone cost, if the company had to also somehow return that material to the earth—pay for the phone’s recycling cost, for example, or contribute to alternate energy research, or make the phone entirely out of materials that were renewable?  A lot more.  A hell of a lot more.

I was going to call this concept, “sustainable pricing” and just like processed food has to have its nutritional content, processed goods have to have their sustainable price printed on the label.  We should know what our lifestyle is actually costing us.

If I buy a chair made of wood, and another made of plastic, I should be able to see the true cost of the plastic one.

Then I sat down in front of my email, and Joel Achenbach has written the cover story to the Washington Post magazine this week.  It has passages like this one:

Earthaven is a low-budget, backwoods advertisement for the alternative view. Its members are attempting to craft a new society, built not around economic growth but around the idea of sustainability and what they call “permaculture,” the goal of creating modes of living that will never damage the planet.

And this one:

“If everyone lived at the lifestyle of Americans,” says Jim McMillan, who works on alternative energy for the Department of Energy, “we’d need five planets.”

It’s time to change something, and I think that a great first step is to stop hiding the internal mechanisms of consumerism from the people who consume.  When I was in elementary school, I got taken to a farm to see how they milked cows.

It was a small farm near Calgary. It probably had 200 cows, and I think they made a decent perentage of income from the tour groups, school and otherwise, they hosted.  But why didn’t they take me to the meat rendering plant?  Why don’t they take school kids to the dump?

Why don’t they take kids to—well, part of the reason is that kids in North America can’t see many of the places where the truly significant industrial process happen.  Kids ought to be taken to Butte, Montana or a clothing factory in Thailand.

But our kids aren’t the ones that get to visit that factory.

Overheard

“The summer weather is expected to last well into next week.”

...who said it?

“Watch your step as you exit the train, and if you’re late, just remember that life is a lot like being on this train: we may not be there yet, but we’re getting there.”

...who said it?

“There are four boxes to be used in defense of liberty: soap, ballot, jury, and ammo. Please use in that order.”

...who said it?

“Description: MySQL server has gone away”

...who said it?

“According to Golf Digest, from 1996 to 2007, Woods made $769,440,709. Golf Digest predicts that, by 2010, Woods will become the world’s first athlete to pass one billion dollars in earnings.”

...who said it?

Comments

 

 

Taking kids to the rendering plant or the dump are great ideas. I know part of the reason I hate throwing things out (vs. recycling or, better yet, reusing) is that my dad would take me along when he had to drive dead-beyond-reusability appliances or yard waste to the dump. A) it stunk and B) there was an awful lot of trash.

 

Posted by Christina  at  1:07 pm on Nov. 19, 2006

 

 

 

David Korten's "When Corporations Rule the World" (1995) talks a bit about sustainable pricing -- I recommend the book. I'd love to see pricetagging as you describe.

Short of government regulation, though, I wonder if the idea would fly (beyond the obvious pickup of already-eco-friendly manufacturers). Perhaps an army of guerilla citizen-pricetaggers could help with the labelling process.

Corporate Responsibility gets a lot more (mainstream) press on this side of the pond, in my estimation, but so far it's all "voluntary", though the government is thinking of levying a Green Tax.

 

Posted by Wesley  at  6:12 pm on Nov. 19, 2006

 

 

 

Going to the dump should be a mandatory field trip. I came across it by "accident" at a crappy job where I drove into the dump in a U-Haul behind all the other garbage vehicles, to dispose of the insulation we ripped out of said crappy job. Needless to say, it was an eye-opening (and nose-closing) experience.

 

Posted by hermitdeb  at  7:19 am on Nov. 20, 2006

 

 

 

Wes,

I was thinking a Web site would be the answer: wiki-powered, by product name and UPC (mark of the devil, etc. etc.)

People could provide their best estimate of what the true price of a product is; I looked it up some more and economists call these "externalities" -- things that aren't taken into account when pricing is done.

Deb and Chri,

Yeah, dump is a great field trip. Where else should school kids go? I think a grocery store warehouse, and a paper producery.

 

Posted by Travis Smith  at  10:41 am on Nov. 20, 2006

 

 

 

It's funny that you mention this. Recently, I've thinking of getting rid of a bunch of stuff. But it made me think, what do I do with this stuff? Do I throw it out or put it in a recycle bin or give it to the Good Will? Will they throw out items I find undesirable or will they sell them to others?

It bothers me that there are so many items that we use daily that wear out or become un-usable. What can we do with things that take up so much space that are no longer wanted?

 

Posted by Kathryn  at  9:09 pm on Nov. 26, 2006

 

 

 

I like the web site idea. It would be a start.

Kathryn -- I was disappointed last time I did a major move at how much of my precious junk was rejected by Goodwill. They wouldn't take my perfectly serviceable bike, for instance, because it had rust. So I left it in the street and it was gone within two hours... The best thing to do is to be there while they go through your stuff, so you can ensure that the items they don't want don't just end up thrown away.

 

Posted by Wesley  at  1:08 am on Nov. 27, 2006

Add a Comment

 

 

Name:


Email:


Location:


URL:


Submit the word you see below:


 

 

 

Your comment:


Remember my personal info


Email me about follow-ups


 

Syndication Links


Click here for the main
XML feed for this blog.



Column only



Side links only



Quotes only

 

I'm Listening To

2007/07/29 11:50

Zero 7
Garden State

MetaBlogs

AboutBlogs

Clients

Humor

Journalism

Los Angeles

Mac

News

Personal 1

Personal 2

Photos

Politics

Other A-F

Other G-Q

Other R-Z

SocialNetworking

Tech 1

Tech 2

Travel

Vancouver 1

Vancouver 2

Vancouver 3

Vancouver 4

BizBlogs

Back to Main

 

Powered by
Expression Engine

 

Copyright 1995 - 2005

 

 

Want Column?

Enter your email address:


It will NEVER be shared.
Unsubscribe

You can scroll right easily by holding down the SHIFT key and using your scroll wheel. (Firefox users trying this will end up jumping to old Web pages until a) Firefox releases a fix, b) they change their settings like so.)