It features about 10 4-person tables, and a line up that took my friend and I 35 minutes to wait through tonight.
The menu is long enough and yet still simple, covering all the basic Mexican foods you might want: enchiladas, chili rellano, tacos, burritos, etc. The smell was fantastic as we waited, though I will say this was the most uniformly Caucasian wait staff I’ve encountered so far. Goes to show, you shouldn’t judge a restaurant by its employees.
The default serving for the burrito here is with an avocado sauce, green and creamy. (I can’t tell you how it tastes because I don’t eat avocado, but I’m told it was delicious.) If you order your burrito “wet,” it comes with a red sauce instead, and costs $4 more. Why $4 more? Is the avocado sauce subsidized by Big Avocado? It’s a mystery to me (though it would explain why every damn sushi roll in this city comes with avocado in it).
But no matter. I paid extra for “wet” and extra again for my “premium” filling, pork tenderloin, ultimately driving the cost up to about $18. My companion’s was beef with an chili rellano to match it, and everything was amazing. My pork, though not stewed, was still spicy and fragrant. His was yummy through and through, though a little small, he said.
The rice was simple; spiced without any mixed-in vegetable matter like peas. Hooray! The beans, perfect—more pinto than black in this case, which is as it should be—and cheese melted over everything in sufficient but not ludicrous quantity.
I should disclose that the accompanying beers, Negro Modelo and Dos Equis, really, really made the burrito go down perfectly, and the chips were so thin and crunchy they could have been made of formica. Accompanying the chips was just enough salsa if you weren’t greedy (I was), and it was none too spicy, which suited my mood and beer consumption.
Two more points of note: despite the fact that it’s pretty low key and casual, the dim lighting and the coziness of the place would make it a good date restaurant. And, if you do have room for dessert, I highly recommend you order the chocolate cake. It’s really rich, totally moist, and tastes pretty darn close to freshly home made. Yes, it’s not Mexican. Neither are you, so just order it and enjoy it.
The only two downsides: the wait, but how can you criticize people for wanting a piece of this action, and the prices, but then again, where else you gonna go for good and cheap Mexican food? Ultimately, It’s not exactly what I wanted, but it satisfices wonderfully, so I give these burritos a 9/10.
Now what? With an actual good burrito found, I’ll probably have a few other Mexican restaurants to test out and share, but without the same strange sense of urgency that’s been driving me this past week. Thanks for following along. In the future, maybe… who does the best Thai food? Naw, that’s crazy.
I used to live across the street from Topanga and never tried their chocolate cake. A tragedy for sure. It even made the VanMag 101 list of local foods to try before you die.
The only criticism I've heard of Topanga is from a Texan friend who is happy there's a good "Mexi-Cali" place in town, but still a dearth of good "Tex-Mex." Who knew!
I think you should come to London and do the restaurant tour here. There are MANY excellent Mexican, Salvadorian and Spanish establishments. How weird is that?!
thank god someone has undertaken this much needed quest/research and posted about it. i will be visiting topanga cafe soon...i had written it off because i knew they were famous for their cake. (not possible in my mind to simultaneously serve good cake and burritos). nevertheless - sounds like the best this ex-SF resident is going to find in Canadia.
You can scroll right easily by holding down the SHIFT key and using your scroll wheel. (Firefox users trying this will end up jumping to old Web pages until a) Firefox releases a fix, b) they change their settings like so.)