In amongst the shipment of things that came up from Los Angeles, is our entire CD collection. There’s about 500 CDs in it.
But we don’t listen to CDs anymore, and in the past 18 months, we haven’t missed them a bit. We don’t listen to CDs in the car, not on the home stereo, nowhere. Our whole collection is digitized, and at 192 kbps or better, and I’ve made backups of the whole thing. So I don’t think we’ll need to re-rip anything ever, either.
At this point, I’m considering what to do with the collection. I’ve come up with the following five possibilities:
1) Sell everything to a used CD store. Pros: money. Cons: Boring
2) Donate the CDs for a tax writeoff. Pros: money (more than 1? Hmmm.) Cons: What do starving single-mom cancer patients need with CDs? Also, boring*boring.
3) Have a big party, give away the CDs to everyone who attends. Pro: See friends! Have fun! Cons: Do we want people to know how much Depeche Mode we purchased?
4) Keep some CDs in the car at all times. Every time I drive somewhere, hand CDs out to pedestrians who get close to the car. Pros: Make someone’s day. Cons: Is this really the best use of my time/money? If I hand someone a Wham! CD, will they be offended?
5) Keep all the CDs in my garage so that I can legally continue to have the MP3 files on my hard drive for when the RIAA comes kicking down my door. (Yes, I know the CRIA should be the ones to kick down my door, but they’re a little more level-headed, whereas I can totally imagine the RIAA coming across the border to get me.) Pros: Can’t be used against me by political opponents like the previous 4 options. Cons: Boring^boring.
So, what do you think? What should we do with our CD collection?
“I find myself thinking of a checklist Wozniak wrote a few years ago describing how to become a genius. His advice was straightforward yet strangely terrible: You must clarify your goals, gain knowledge through spaced repetition, preserve health, work steadily, minimize stress, refuse interruption, and never resist sleep when tired. This should lead to radically improved intelligence and creativity. The only cost: turning your back on every convention of social life.”
“Twenty years from now you will be more disappointed by the things you didn’t do than by the ones you did. So throw off the bowlines. Sail away from the safe harbor. Catch the trade winds in your sails. Explore. Dream.”
I just said last night I was hoping to upgrade my Depeche Mode tapes to CD. And um, my birthday is just around the corner.
Also, for one of my museum programs, I need at least 26 CDs for a kids' recycling project. They are going to make holders for playing cards, thus any bad CDs would be great!
We have gone the store them in a storage room option. I still fear the RIAA, so they are all safe in boxes in a storage unit in an undisclosed location.
Something about me wants to hoard them and I can't let them go...
Posted by Laura Moncur at 11:57 am on Mar. 28, 2006
I say mail them to the RIAA, with a letter explaining that you need them to store them for you so you can continue to use the digital copies legally.
Pros: maybe you could start a trend.
Cons: have to pay for postage.
Hmm, maybe there's a business in this... rent a warehouse in some cheap area and keep everyone's physical CDs on file. I'd pay a yearly subscription fee...
As an anal-retentive and a quality-conscious music fan, I say keep them. There will someday be lossless formats that produce files no bigger than a 128kbps mp3. then you will need to re-rip.
That possibility already haunts my own dreams...
Posted by Justin at 4:02 pm on Mar. 29, 2006
I like option 2. Single moms and cancer patients both need them to cheer up. Homeless people without players, less so, but still not a bad idea. That also frees up time from Option 4, which could be better spent showing me how to back up our entire collection without using up all the piddly harddrive space from our laptop!
haven't you always wanted to have 500 coasters? no? hmm... use them to tile your kitchen? put them on chains around your neck to make stylish and funky jewelry? roll them down a hill in races and allow the neighbourhood kids to place bets? man, i am no good at this. my suggestion is to not give them to me because I would do something lame with them.
donating them to cancer victims, etc., has a certain appeal -- until i stop to think about how many utterly depressing, depressing music cds are part of this collection. i mean, isn't wrong to give someone with terminal cancer "dear god" by XTC? and then there's all that fabulously uplifting the cure...
You can scroll right easily by holding down the SHIFT key and using your scroll wheel. (Firefox users trying this will end up jumping to old Web pages until a) Firefox releases a fix, b) they change their settings like so.)